Compare Two Characters
RL.5.3
Read the text, then answer the questions.
The Mill: Ivy Sallow's Account
We knew by the thread. You cannot work a loom for twenty-two years and not notice when the good cotton stops coming. From about the March, it was the cheap stuff, and it broke. So we knew something. What we did not know was how long we had, and that is the part I mind. I could have been looking. My sister found work in Derby that spring and asked me twice. I said the mill would see me out. He stood on a crate on the Friday and told us. Somebody asked how long he had known. He said he would rather not say. That was the answer, really.
- 1. What does turning down her sister twice tell you about Ivy?
- 2. Compare Ivy's view of her own choices with her view of Whately's.
Pandora
The gods made Pandora and gave her, between them, everything: beauty, skill, a voice, curiosity. They also gave her a jar, and told her not to open it. They did not say what was in it. She kept it for a long time. The story is usually told as though she opened it immediately. She did not. When she did lift the lid, out came sickness, hunger, grief and every trouble that has since been ordinary. She got the lid back on with one thing still inside. That thing was hope. And people have argued for three thousand years about whether keeping it in was a mercy or the cruellest part of all.
- 1. What does "She kept it for a long time" add to her character?
- 2. Compare Pandora's gifts with what happens to her.
LessonPrint · RL.5.3 · Set 11 · free to copy for classroom use