Skip to content
LessonPrint

What Is Wrong With That Argument? is a free printable Grade 3 to Grade 5 social studies worksheet on critiquing an argument, aligned to Common Core standard D4.4.3-5. It prints 8 questions with an answer key on its own sheet of paper, in 25 versions that each ask different questions, so no two pupils in the class work from the same page. Print it from the browser or download it as a PDF — no account, no email.

Set 5 of 25 · the same problems every time you open this link.

Next setLesson plan

One paper per pupil

12345678910111213141516171819202122232425

Set 1 has all 25 in a single PDF. All 25 sets ask different questions.

What Is Wrong With That Argument?

D4.4.3-5

NameDate

Circle the best answer.

1.'The railway was good because trains are fast.' What is wrong with it?
  • A.Railways are bad
  • B.Speed alone does not show the valley was better off
  • C.Trains are not fast
2.'The boatmen were lazy, so they lost their work.' What is wrong?
  • A.It blames the people without any evidence, when the cargo moved to rail
  • B.It is too short
  • C.Boatmen were strong
3.What makes an argument about 1846 strong?
  • A.Confidence
  • B.Length
  • C.A clear claim, evidence from several sources, and an answer to the other side
4.'The 2015 book is right because it is recent.' What is wrong?
  • A.Being recent is not evidence; the claim must be tested against records
  • B.Old books are always right
  • C.2015 is not recent
5.'Everybody welcomed the line, as the paper shows.' What is wrong?
  • A.One newspaper cannot show what everybody thought, and the petition disagrees
  • B.The word everybody is too long
  • C.Newspapers are always false
6.An argument uses one source and ignores one that disagrees. What is wrong?
  • A.It has chosen the evidence to fit the claim
  • B.Disagreement is rude
  • C.One source is always enough
7.An argument gives a claim and no evidence. What is the strongest reply?
  • A.Say it louder
  • B.Say it is wrong
  • C.Ask what evidence would support it
8.An argument admits what it cannot prove. Is that a weakness?
  • A.Yes, it is shorter
  • B.No: it is a strength, because the reader can see its limits
  • C.Yes, it shows doubt

LessonPrint · D4.4.3-5 · Set 5 · free to copy for classroom use

Answer key — What Is Wrong With That Argument?

Set 5. Prints on its own sheet.

  1. 1.Speed alone does not show the valley was better off
  2. 2.It blames the people without any evidence, when the cargo moved to rail
  3. 3.A clear claim, evidence from several sources, and an answer to the other side
  4. 4.Being recent is not evidence; the claim must be tested against records
  5. 5.One newspaper cannot show what everybody thought, and the petition disagrees
  6. 6.It has chosen the evidence to fit the claim
  7. 7.Ask what evidence would support it
  8. 8.No: it is a strength, because the reader can see its limits

More practice for D4.4.3-5

Judge how good an argument is.

Teaching this next? Finding the Hole in an Argument is the 45-minute plan for it, with the misconceptions to expect.

All Grade 3 to Grade 5 worksheets

Last reviewed 2026-09-05. Aligned to D4.4.3-5 of the C3 Framework for Social Studies State Standards.