What It Takes for Granted
D2.His.11.3-5
Look at the source, then answer the questions.
Letters to a National Newspaper
Three letters printed on the correspondence page of a national newspaper in 1951. YOUR CORRESPONDENTS WRITE Sir: my family has waited six years. The figures mean nothing to us. Sir: the councils build too slowly. Let private firms compete. Sir: the villages are forgotten while the cities are rebuilt. The editor notes that all three writers gave their addresses. Letters may be shortened for space.
- 1. What do these three letters have in common?
- 2. What does the page not tell you?
A Contested National History
An extract from a national history published in 2011. This is a SECONDARY work making a causal claim other historians reject. REBUILDING: WHAT ACTUALLY DECIDED IT The author argues that shortages, not politics, set the pace of rebuilding. She points to the broadcast admitting bricks and timber ran short. Critics reply that the choice to use councils slowed the work. The author concedes she cannot separate the two causes with certainty. She rests her case on the quarterly figures the minister promised.
- 1. How confident is the author in her own claim?
- 2. What does this extract not tell you?
LessonPrint · D2.His.11.3-5 · Set 10 · free to copy for classroom use